Equal Pay Day | The Race and Gender Wage GapDeborah Swerdlow Mar 14, 2023 10:00 AM
On March 14 of this year, people across the U.S. will mark Equal Pay Day, the symbolic day each calendar year when a woman’s earnings “catch up” to a man’s earnings from the previous year. Because white women on average earn 83 cents on the dollar compared to men’s earnings, it takes a woman almost 16 months to earn what a man earns in just 12.
But that 83-cent statistic is not an average for all women, compared to men. For many women, Equal Pay Day doesn’t come until much later in the year.
Compared to white, non-Hispanic men—who are used as the benchmark because they are the largest group in the workforce—women of color often experience a much larger pay gap. For example:
The point of marking each of these Equal Pay Days is to draw attention to the various pay gaps and prompt discussion about what’s behind them—and how to end them.
Understanding the gender pay gap
There are many ways to slice and dice the data, but no matter how you cut it, women’s earnings typically lag behind men’s. The American Association of University Women (AAUW) finds a gender pay gap in every state, in every age range, and for women of all education levels.
There are several factors that contribute to the pay gap. One key cause is occupational segregation: women often work in fields that pay less, such as education and administrative support, while men are more heavily represented in higher-paying fields like science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM).
Occupational segregation is rooted in gendered perceptions and stereotypes of what men and women are “good” at. It makes a clear divide between “women’s work” vs. “men’s work.” From early years in school, many girls are unconsciously steered into certain fields, and unfortunately, those fields often pay less.
But even within the same occupation, women tend to earn less than men. After controlling for other factors besides industry that can affect pay, economists attribute 38% of the gender wage gap to the effects of discrimination. Although gender discrimination in employment is technically illegal, it still happens, either blatantly or unconsciously, due to implicit bias.
Why women of color experience larger pay gaps
The larger pay gap that women of color experience is a textbook example of intersectionality. As women, they face the structural barriers and gender-based discrimination described above. And as people of color, they face additional structural barriers and race-based discrimination, which exacerbates their pay gap.
An intersectional lens, like the one used by the Building Movement Project in its report Race to Lead: Women of Color in the Nonprofit Sector , sheds light on how race and gender interact to produce a larger pay gap and make it harder for women of color to advance to higher-paying jobs. For example, the report survey found that women of color were more likely to face barriers to career advancement and be relegated to lower-level roles (which tend to be lower-paying), relative to white women and men of color. This trend remained even when survey respondents reported that they held advanced degrees or had pursued additional training.
“[There is] often an assumption that a person of color is supposed to be working in an administrative role, and so I was automatically dissuaded from applying to managerial positions (despite having a master’s degree),” said one multiracial women who responded to the survey, illustrating that the same stereotypes that drive occupational segregation by gender also segregate women of color into lower-paying fields.
The research also found that women of color reported less access to mentors in their organizations and were less likely to receive regular feedback on their work—two things that can be critical to professional development and advancement.
“When the senior leadership identifies and grooms a colleague they think would be an impactful ‘face’ for this organization, that person is white, male, and heterosexual,” said one Black woman. “In one instance, I have far more experience and education, yet am not being groomed in this way.”
What you can do
If there are many contributing factors to the larger pay gap for women of color, then there are just as many opportunities to intervene and interrupt the status quo. Even one person can start to shift the culture and break down the barriers that allow the pay gap to persist.
1. Share your salary
One thing you can do right away is share your salary with your peers, especially with women of color in your field. If you’re not comfortable sharing the exact number, you can share a range or your starting salary. “Ask A Manager” expert Alison Green reminds us that employers can’t legally prevent nonsupervisory employees from talking about their pay with each other.
You can also enter your salary on comparison websites or surveys like Idealist Salaries. If you’ve worked at a U.S. nonprofit full time within the last three years, you can input your information and compare your salary with social-impact professionals across the sector.
Sharing your salary can reduce pay gaps. Greater salary transparency allows people to discover if they are being underpaid, and offers the necessary information to advocate for fairer compensation.
2. Negotiate your salary, and help others do the same
Studies show that women are less likely than men to negotiate their salaries, which can contribute to the gender pay gap. If you’re a woman reading this post and you have never negotiated your salary, now’s the time to change that. Check out our tips for negotiating your salary and benefits.
If you’re not currently up for a review or a raise, read up on the same resources linked to above and then offer to role-play with a friend who’s about to negotiate their salary. Take notes on how they can be more assertive and make a stronger case for their requested salary—and give them the encouragement they need to negotiate confidently!
3. Advocate for change
The Building Movement Project suggests organizational changes that can help reduce pay inequities for women of color, such as anti-bias training and pay transparency. While these are large changes that one person can’t make overnight, you can band together with colleagues and lobby your organization to take action.
It’s often safer for white employees to initiate these conversations because they don’t have to contend with harmful racial stereotypes like the “angry Black woman”—a theme that came up often in the write-in responses and focus groups that informed the Race to Lead report. Speaking up in these instances is one example of how white people can use their privilege to be an ally in the workplace.
If you want to push for change on a larger scale, find organizations in your area that work to address pay inequities. Advocating for major policy changes at a state or national level—like banning employers from asking job candidates for their salary history—can help to ensure that salaries are based more on merit and equity.
Did you enjoy this post? There's plenty more where this came from! Subscribe here for updates.Subscribe NEGOTIATING EQUITY Deborah Swerdlow Mar 14, 2023 10:00 AM
As a nonprofit advocacy professional living in Washington, D.C., Deborah works with groups across the country to educate their communities and lawmakers about public policies that can help low-income residents make ends meet. She is passionate about helping people connect their interests to a cause they believe in and empowering them to take action.