Strategic Human Resource Management

The Performance Privilege: How Top Performers Receive Different Treatment for Workplace Misconduct

Available from GCheck

The Performance Privilege: How Top Performers Receive Different Treatment for Workplace Misconduct

Content Summary

An employee knowingly submits the same expense twice. Does their performance record affect how a manager responds? Based on a November 2026 survey of 2,000 employed U.S. workers, including 893 managers, GCheck's The Performance Privilege Report examines how managers judge identical workplace misconduct when the employee's performance level changes. Through a randomized experiment, the report measures differences in the benefit of the doubt, disciplinary recommendations, policy exceptions, and coworkers' expectations of fair treatment.

The report introduces the Performance Privilege, the tendency for an employee's performance level to influence how managers interpret and respond to identical conduct. In the experiment, managers were 1.8 times as likely to support a policy exception for a top performer as for a typical performer, even after the violation was confirmed as intentional. Meanwhile, 81% of managers believe company policies should apply equally regardless of performance, yet 59% say high performers receive more leniency at their organizations. The findings point to a specific weakness in workplace accountability: exceptions made without consistent standards. The report closes with practical recommendations for HR leaders, including written justification for policy exceptions, consistent documentation of misconduct, and safe channels for employees to raise concerns about unequal treatment.

Access this content

Choose an option below

Your content has been opened.

Please verify you are a human before downloading this content.

Please verify you are a human before adding this content to your library.


Register to access this content


Verify your email to access this content

Code sent. Enter it in the modal

Your content has been opened.

Please verify you are a human before opening this content.

Why do I need to verify I’m human?

Please verify you are a human before opening this content.

Your content has been opened.

Please verify you are a human before downloading this content.

Please verify you are a human before opening this content.

The content will open in a new window. You may need to allow popups for this site.